grilling 24x7 logo charcoal picture new york strip steaks hot wings on the charcoal grill

How Much Charcoal?


Grilling Tools

Tailgating Recipes



Recent Updates

Search My Recipes

Apr 16, 2011

Fluffernutter Cups

Every once in a while Mrs. Grilling24x7 comes up with a real winner that compliments my grilling perfectly. On the menu today was two simple NY strips, potatoes and a grilled veggie. But what about dessert? She came up with Fluffernutter Peanut Butter Cups. What an amazing treat! Take a look at this, it is the perfect party dessert as not only does it taste amazing but it is a fun conversation piece.

homemade fluffernutter peanut butter cups

1 cup milk chocolate chips
1 cup semisweet chocolate chips
Marshmallow Fluff
3/4 cup all natural peanut butter
1/3 cup powdered sugar
4 T crushed graham crackers (about 4 crackers)

To start we mixed the semisweet and milk chocolate chips in a bowl and microwaved it until it melts. Then we pulled out about 12 standard muffin tin paper liners and spooned the melted chocolate mix into the bottom of the liners. About 1/4 inch of chocolate works just fine. Use a spoon to spread the chocolate a little up the sides of the liner. We then put the tins into the fridge to allow the chocolate to solidify (about 10 minutes). While the chocolate liners are solidifying in the fridge, mix together the peanut butter, graham cracker crumbs, powdered sugar and pinch of salt in a bowl. Make sure the peanut butter mixture is smooth. Spoon the peanut butter on top of the solidified chocolate, right in the middle.

peanut butter cup with marshmallow

Take about a tablespoon of marshmallow fluff and gently place it on top of the peanut butter. Marshmallow fluff naturally flattens out and runs at room temperature so let these sit for 5-10 minutes so the marshmallow flattens out a bit on top of the peanut butter.

homemade peanut butter cups

Once this happens, put your leftover chocolate chip mixture back into the microwave to get it soft again. Then spoon the chocolate on top of the marshmallow allowing it to run down the sides of the marshmallow and connect with the chocolate on the bottom and sides.

marshmallow fluffernutters

Put the whole Fluffernutter cup back in the fridge to allow the chocolate to set once again (about 10 more minutes). Serve and enjoy! These are a great dessert to accompany any grilled meal. And what fun these are to serve to your friends. The graham cracker and powdered sugar adds an amazing flavor to the peanut butter; it tastes just like what you get in the real Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. Then the addition of the marshmallow fluff reminds me of the amazing fluffernutter sandwiches I used to make as a kid! What an awesome dessert. Mrs. Grilling24x7 really outdid herself this time!

homemade peanut butter fluffernutter cups

5.0 stars based on 12 reviews

Prep time: 10 min; Cook time: 10 min; Total time: 20 min.
Yield: 12cups

Note: This recipe is modifed from the Have Cake, Will Travel Peanut Butter Cup recipe. What a winner!

Recent posts

HTML Comment Box is loading comments...

By John Thomas
Find me on Google+
Copyright 2008-2014

rss feed twitter facebook
Print Friendly and PDF

Indirect vs. Direct Heat Grilling
- on Char-Broil "Live"

Green Chile Double Cheeseburger
- on Char-Broil "Live"

Easy Garlic Marinade
- on Char-Broil "Live"

Photo and Recipe Archive
Click to Expand
Each Heading or Search

John Thomas Char-Broil All Star Blogger

Most Popular on

Bacon Wrapped Onion Rings with a Spicy Sriracha Dipping Sauce - Healthy Onion Ring Recipe
How to grill a steak on a charcoal grill - Grilling24x7
A homemade bbq sauce recipe, the whiskey sour bbq sauce recipe
An easy recipe for homemade guacamole on top of a bacon guacamole burger - perfect tailgate recipe
A Baltimore Maryland Style Pit Beef Sandwich Recipe Just like the Maryland State Fair
an easy homemade gyro recipe using sliced brats and topped with an easy homemade tzatziki sauce
pulled pork tacos with spicy sriracha cole slaw for leftover pulled pork
sliced brisket recipe
chili dog recipe
easy bobby flay rib glaze
homemade fast food from mcdonalds
rotisserie chicken on webers rotisserie attachment
grilled MD style shrimp with old bay seasoning steamed

Grilling24x7 Char-Broil Grill Online Coupon - Doesn't expire - Free coupon code for gas grill charcoal grill

Grilling24x7 Beer Bottle Opener Keychain - For Sale - Grilling24x7

Grilling24x7 Bottle Opener

Subscribe to Grilling 24x7 Recipes via Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Pit Barrel Cooker Review - Spare Ribs and Thanksgiving Turkey on the PBC -


Guest Posts and Partners

Contemporary Dining Suites, Dining Sets and Dining Furniture With Furn-On

Replacement Weber Flavorizer Bars for Great Performance!

Top Chef University App Review

Quality Grill Parts

A Few of My Favorite Grilling Sites/Friends

Another Pint Please

Patio Daddio BBQ



Big Green Craig

I Hate JJ Redick
Baltimore Sports Blog

BBQ Dry Rubs

Homemade Pizza Recipes at PizzaPie24x7!

More Stuff

a thermapen grilling thermometer

a thermapen grilling thermometer

I get commission if you purchase through the above 3 links!